The American Catholic

Politics & Culture from a Catholic perspective
  • Home
  • Comments Policy
  • Contributors
  • What is The American Catholic?
 

Catholic Political Thought & John Locke: Part II

Saturday, October 23, 2010 \PM\.\Sat\.

by Joe Hargrave

In the previous part I showed how Locke’s argument for government by consent was similar to, and may have even been influenced by, that of St. Robert Bellarmine. I also showed how some of the more well-known early-modern political theorists who dreamed of powerful authoritarian regimes also dreamed of obliterating the Church as an obstacle to their fruition. Now I will argue that there is a clear overlap between the political theory of John Locke, and that of Pope Leo XIII, the pope who is responsible for Catholic social teaching as we know it today. In the final part of this series I will address why these overlaps are important, and what they mean in our contemporary political situation.

Read the rest of this entry »

3 Comments | Uncategorized | Tagged: Catholic Social Teaching, First Treatise, First Treatise of Civil Government, God Locke & Equality, Immortale Dei, Jeremy Waldron, John Locke, Karl Marx, Natural Law, Natural Rights, Peter Laslett, Pope Leo XIII, Private Property, Rerum Novarum, Robert Filmer, Second Treatise, Second treatise of civil government, state of nature, Theories of Surplus Value, Thomas Aquinas | Permalink
Posted by Bonchamps


Catholic Distributarianism: A Preemptive FAQ

Friday, September 10, 2010 \AM\.\Fri\.

I’ll begin by stating that part of the blame or praise for this post ought to go to Christopher Blosser and David Jones for their excellent overview and commentary on the ongoing political/economic dispute between Catholic Distributists and Catholic libertarians.

I wish I could easily come up with a logical, smooth flow to all of these points. But really I just want to get them out there, no matter how disjointed in appearance.

Finally, I really mean it this time: we will have a respectful discussion on this topic, or none at all. That means certain people and their comments will likely be banned from the discussion. It will not be possible to avoid charges of “being afraid” to debate with such indestructible champions of the one true political philosophy, given their amazing ability to rule out all other possible reasons, including their coarse and offensive personal behavior, as to why no one wishes to engage in discussions with them. C’est la vie.

The best way to contribute here, though, is to ask questions that I can answer for this FAQ!

*

Where does the word “Distributarian” come from?

The word “Distributarian” was pejoratively applied to me and a few others who have attempted to blend libertarian and Distributist ideas by those not so enamored with the project. Since I see it as a good thing, I don’t mind wearing the label as a badge of honor.

What is a Distributarian?

It is one who does not see a necessary conflict between the basic propositions of Distributism and libertarianism, and insofar as possible, seeks to incorporate both of them into their social vision.

What are these propositions?

The following propositions are both necessary and sufficient for each ideology:

Of Distributism: property should be as widely distributed as possible.

Of libertarianism: social relationships should be as voluntary as possible.

Naturally some doctrinaires will dislike the wording “as ___ as possible”; why should we care about what is possible when great ideas are at stake? Either they exist full-fledged without imperfection in the world or they may as well not exist at all! If we move past this childish expectation and begin with the possible, I think we will find that there is no contradiction between these propositions.

Distributism and libertarianism challenge each other in a good way. Distributism challenges libertarianism to move beyond individual autonomy and articulate a vision of the common good; libertarianism challenges Distributism to clearly articulate how property distribution ought to come about – through force, or through consent?

Not only do they challenge each other; they compliment each other. Property owners will thrive in an environment of economic freedom; genuine liberty will thrive as it is rooted in solid social institutions based upon private property. As property ownership will increase the self-sufficiency of individuals, families, and communities, it will decrease dependency upon the state.

Read the rest and comment here.

And please note that this is a work in progress!

Comments Off on Catholic Distributarianism: A Preemptive FAQ | Uncategorized | Tagged: Anarchism, Catholic Social Teaching, Distributism, Edward Feser, John Locke, Joseph Schumpeter, Libertarianism, Murray Rothbard, Natural Rights, Political Philosophy, Political Theory, Pope Leo XIII, Pope Pius XI, property, Property Rights, Quadragesimo Anno, Redistribution of wealth, Rerum Novarum, Scott McDermott, Second treatise of civil government, theory of property, wealth redistribution | Permalink
Posted by Bonchamps


Stealing From The Poor

Friday, July 30, 2010 \AM\.\Fri\.

This article originally appeared on The New Theological Movement written by Reginaldus on July 29, 2010 Anno Domini.  Re-posted with permission.

18th Sunday in Ordinary Time, Luke 12:13-21

The rich man of this Sunday’s Gospel is blessed with a bountiful harvest. Rather than thanking God for this gift, he hoards the grain in his barns – his heart is possessed by his possessions. At the moment of death, the Lord calls him a fool, for he was not rich in what matters to God.

The Fathers of the Church, and St. Thomas Aquinas following them, see in this parable a strong teaching of social justice. Their teachings have in turn been integrated into the Social Doctrine of the Church. Here we will consider St. Thomas’ exposition of the doctrine as well as several important quotations from the Church Fathers.

The common destination of all goods and right to private property

We must first affirm that man has a right to own private property. All men have a natural right to make use of material goods. According to positive human law, men also have a right to private property – this is necessary for the good order of society and the proper care of the goods themselves, it also serves as a means of restraining greed and inciting toward generosity (a man can give alms only if he has some property of his own).

However, it is equally clear in the Church’s Tradition, as expressed by the Fathers of the Church and magisterial teachings, that the right to private property is subordinate to the universal destination of all goods. That is, the right to private property cannot be extended to the point of depriving others of the basic material necessities of life. Every man has the right to the material necessities of life – when he is deprived of these, while another has excess wealth, a grave injustice has occurred.

Read the rest of this entry »

7 Comments | Uncategorized | Tagged: Catechism of the Catholic Church, Catena Aurea, Catholic Social Doctrine, Centesimus Annus, Church Fathers, Common Good, De Nabuthe, Gaudium et Spes, Good Order of Sociey, Greed, Holy Bible, Holy Gospel of Saint Luke, Magisterium, Natural Rights, Poor and Vulnerable, Pope John Paul II, Pope Leo XIII, Pope Paul VI, Pope Pius XI, Pope Saint Gregory the Great, Populorum Progressio, Positive Human Law, Poverty, Private Property, Quadragesimo Anno, Regula Pastoralis, Rerum Novarum, Sacred Tradition, Saint Ambrose, Saint Basil the Great, Saint Bede, Saint John Chrysostom, Saint Thomas Aquinas, Summa Theologica, The Decretals, The New Theological Movement, Vatican II, Wealth | Permalink
Posted by Tito Edwards


Liberal Capitalism and Catholic Economic Theory

Thursday, January 21, 2010 \PM\.\Thu\.

The so-called American conservative movement is not conservative in the sense that many of its proponents would suggest. In reality, American conservatism, in many ways seeks to preserve and reassert classical liberalism. In fact, the entirety of the American political spectrum is liberal in different ways and varying degrees—but it is unmistakably and manifestly liberal.

This should come as no surprise since many of the Founding Fathers were men of the Enlightenment and there is no more obvious case than that of Thomas Jefferson, the author of that quintessential Enlightenment masterpiece The Declaration of Independence. The philosophical paradigm by 1776 had already shifted—anthropology was evolving toward an increasingly false view of man and the natural law (because the philosophical concept of “nature” was changing) was something different than that articulated by classical philosophers, which had been incorporated into the Christian tradition.

The American legal tradition seeking to adhere to the letter of the social contract, i.e. The Constitution of the United States of America, seems to have individual liberty at issue in every question of law. This, to be sure, is not something to be regarded as a problem in and of itself, insofar as the operative definition of liberty is not philosophically false and the norms of justice, in the classical sense, are not contradicted.

To the learned mind, it is patently clear that the predominant philosophical paradigm, anthropological assumptions on human nature, concept of the nation-state, view of society, of freedom, of responsibility, and so forth found in the Western world is undoubtedly borne of Enlightenment thinking. The United States is most certainly no exception. In America, across the political spectrum, there is a dubious philosophical premise, that of an abstract ideal of autonomy, which, no matter how admirable or attractive it may seem, is radically incomplete. Indeed, man does possess a free will, but the form of freedom requires content. Read the rest of this entry »

41 Comments | Uncategorized | Tagged: Catholic Intellectual Tradition, Catholic Social Teaching, Collectivism, Economic Science, Economics, False Anthropology, False Philosophies, Individualism, Jacque Maritain, Laissez-Faire, Liberal Capitalism, Modernity, Natural Law, Natural Rights, Papal Teaching, Political Theory, Pope Benedict XVI, Pope John Paul II, Pope John XXIII, Pope Leo XIII, Pope Pius XI, Preferential Option for the Poor, Role of Government, Social Economy, Social Justice, Socialism, Solidarity, Theological Anthropology, Venerable Pope Pius XII | Permalink
Posted by Eric Brown


  • Recent Posts

    • “A riot is the language of the unheard” – Understanding Martin Luther King in context
    • 10 Most Cited Arguments In Favor of the Mandate
    • The Battle of New Orleans The Hollywood Way
    • Andrew Jackson: Hero, Heel or Both?
    • “Feed your Flock” Superbowl Ad
    • Pope approves restricted use of condoms in battle against AIDS?
    • We Are At the-american-catholic.com
    • TAC Down Until Sunday Evening, November 14
    • Profiles in Fecklessness
    • Rocky Top
    • A Question for Our Readers
    • MacIntyre on Money
    • Jihadists, Truth and Father Raymond J. de Souza
    • The European Union: A Disaster for Equality, Etc.
    • CS Lewis Explains Why We Honor Veterans
  • Recent Comments

    Leo Holahan on 10 Most Cited Arguments In Fav…
    Rez Families on Sex, the Fall, and the Re…
    Kewaza on Atheist Praises Missionaries
    The Christian Vegan on Andrew Jackson: Hero, Heel or…
    Monica on Simply Outrageous
    Jacques from france on How Europe Sees America
    Tommy on An Example to Us All
    Mariana on Marriage Improvement
    redmetta on Clear Creek Monastery
    best carry holster on Should Catholics Own Guns…
    รายได้เสริมทางเน็ต on Pope Paul VI and The Smoke of…
    witnesstolife on Archbishop Niederauer Instruct…
    dota 2 beta start da… on Married Priests From the First…
    Lying Worthless Poli… on Pelosi, Saint Joseph and the C…
    truck guide on On Distributism and the Futili…
  • Top Posts – Last 24 Hours

    • In Defense of Catholic Romanticism
    • Polls and polls and polls and polls and polls
  • RealCatholicTV.com

  • Get Our Feed!

     Subscribe in a reader

    Subscribe in Bloglines

    Catholic Homepage

    Add to My AOL

    Add to Technorati Favorites

    Add to The Free Dictionary

    Add to Excite MIX

    Add to netvibes

    Subscribe to American Catholic

  • Enter your email address to subscribe to this blog and receive notifications of new posts by email.

    Join 141 other followers
  • August 2022
    M T W T F S S
    1234567
    891011121314
    15161718192021
    22232425262728
    293031  
    « Nov    
  • Archives

    • November 2014
    • March 2012
    • May 2011
    • December 2010
    • November 2010
    • October 2010
    • September 2010
    • August 2010
    • July 2010
    • June 2010
    • May 2010
    • April 2010
    • March 2010
    • February 2010
    • January 2010
    • December 2009
    • November 2009
    • October 2009
    • September 2009
    • August 2009
    • July 2009
    • June 2009
    • May 2009
    • April 2009
    • March 2009
    • February 2009
    • January 2009
    • December 2008
    • November 2008
    • October 2008
  • Catholic Bible Links

    • Biblia Clerus
    • Douay-Rheims
    • Latin Vulgate
    • New American Bible (USCCB)
    • Revised Std Version Cth Ed
    • Scripture Catholic
    • Septuagint/Vulgate/Douay
    • St Paul Ctr … Biblical Theology
    • Sunday Scripture Study
  • Catholic Blogroll

    • A Catholic Mom in Hawaii
    • Acts of the Apostasy
    • Against The Grain
    • An Examined Life
    • and sometimes tea
    • Biblical Evidence for Catholici…
    • Bonfire of the Vanities
    • Cahiers Péguy
    • Catholic Free Shipping Blog
    • Catholic Light
    • Catholic Phoenix
    • Conversion Diary
    • Cosmos-Liturgy-Sex
    • CVSTOS FIDEI
    • Disputations
    • Fidelity to the Word
    • Gulf Coast Catholic
    • la nouvelle théologie
    • Mary Meets Dolly
    • Per Christum
    • Riparians at the Gate
    • Sacramentum Vitae
    • SoCon or Bust
    • The Catholic Comedy
    • The Catholic Key Blog
    • The Curt Jester
    • The Divine Life
    • The Minor Premise
    • Video Meliora
    • Vivificat!
    • Whosoever Desires
  • Catholic Commentary

    • Catholic and Enjoying It!
    • Catholic Exchange
    • Catholic Fire
    • CVSTOS FIDEI
    • Damian Thompson
    • DarwinCatholic
    • Dyspeptic Mutterings
    • Evangelical Catholicism
    • George Weigel
    • Journeys in Alterity
    • Lair of the Catholic Cavemen
    • National Catholic Register
    • Non Nobis
    • Opinionated Catholic
    • Standing on My Head
    • Ten Reasons
    • The Catholic Thing
    • The Pertinacious Papist
    • What Does the Prayer Really…
  • Catholic New Media Links

    • Catholic Cartoon Blog
    • Catholic Media Review
    • Decent Films Guide
    • Eternal Word TV Network
    • Faith & Family
    • Gloria TV
    • Gulf Coast Catholic
    • RealCatholicTV.com
    • Rome Reports
    • Sonitus Sanctus
    • sqpn
    • The Catholicism Project
    • Vatican YouTube Channel
  • Catholic News Links

    • Catholic Culture
    • Catholic Online
    • Catholic Tide
    • Life Site News
    • National Catholic Register
    • New Advent – Catholic News
    • Notes on the Culture Wars
    • PewSitter.com
    • Real Clear Religion
    • Spirit Daily
    • Zenit
  • Catholic Orthodox Links

    • Canon Law by Dr. Ed Peters
    • CVSTOS FIDEI
    • FSSP
    • Gulf Coast Catholic
    • Legion of Mary
    • Musica Sacra
    • National Cthlc Bioethics Center
    • Natural Family Planning
    • Opus Dei
    • RORATE CÆLI
    • The Distributist Review
    • The New Liturgical Movement
  • Catholic Political Links

    • American Papist
    • Blackadders Lair
    • Catholic Advocate
    • CatholicVote.com
    • Civics Geeks
    • Creative Minority Report
    • CVSTOS FIDEI
    • For the Greater Glory
    • InsideCatholic.com
    • Matt Glassman
    • Mirror of Justice
    • Pro Ecclesia
    • Southern Appeal
    • The Anchoress
    • The Cranky Conservative
    • Thoughts of a Regular Guy
  • Catholic Radio Links

    • Ave Maria Radio
    • EWTN Radio
    • Relevant Radio
    • Vatican Radio
  • Catholic Resources

    • African-American Outreach
    • Black Catholic History
    • Byzantine Cthlc Church (US)
    • Catechism (CCC)
    • Catholic Dads Resources
    • Catholic Encyclopedia
    • Catholic Free Shipping
    • Catholic Liturgical Library
    • Catholic Search Engine
    • Catholic Social Doctrine
    • Catholic Social Teaching
    • Catholic Theology Resources
    • Catholics Come Home
    • Code of Canon Law
    • Compendium of the CCC
    • Cth Legal Immigration Net Inc
    • CVSTOS FIDEI
    • Decree on Ecumenism
    • Domestic Church
    • Early Christian Writings
    • Ecumenical Councils
    • Faithful Citizenship
    • Gulf Coast Catholic
    • Mass Times
    • National Cthlc AIDS Network
    • Natl Fellowship of Cthlc Men
    • Papal Encyclicals
    • Pope John Paul II Writings
    • Universalis
  • Catholic TV Links

    • CatholicTV
    • RealCatholicTV.com
  • Catholic Websites

    • Acton Institute
    • Against The Grain
    • Bellarmine Veritas Ministry
    • Black Catholics for Life
    • C-FAM
    • Cardinal Newman Society
    • Catholic Answers
    • Catholic Environmental Justice
    • Catholic Health Care USA
    • Catholic Hierarchy
    • Catholic Leadership Institute
    • Catholic League
    • Catholic Med Assoc
    • Catholic PeaceBuilding Net…
    • Catholic Relief Services
    • Clear Creek Monastery
    • Courage
    • Cth Resource For Porn Addicts
    • Cthlc Campaign for Hmn Dev…
    • Cthlc Education Resource Cntr
    • Cthlc Worker Movement
    • Cthlcs for the Common Good
    • Cths Against Capital Pnshmnt
    • Emmaus Ministries
    • Fathers for Good
    • FOCUS
    • Gulf Coast Catholic
    • Human Life International
    • Invisible Children
    • Knights of Columbus
    • Knights of Saint Peter Clav…
    • Make Poverty History
    • March for Life
    • Mercy Corps
    • Militia of the Immaculata
    • National Black Cthlc Congress
    • National Catholic Register
    • National Cthlc Youth Confere…
    • Pope Benedict XVI Fan Club
    • Priests for Life
    • Pro-Life America
    • Project Vote Smart
    • Pure Love Club
    • Rachels Vineyard
    • The Rosarium
    • USCCB
    • Vatican: English Site
    • Vatican: Latin Site
    • Word On Fire Cthlc Ministries
  • Jewish Websites

    • Pave the Way Foundation
  • Muslim Websites

    • Am Islamic Forum for Dmcrcy
    • Center for Islamic Pluralism
    • Muslim Canadian Congress
  • Orthodox Blogs

    • Notes on Arab Orthodoxy
    • The Burning Bush
  • Other Christian Blogs

    • Midwest Conservative Journal
    • The Anglo-Catholic
    • The Buck Stops Here
    • What's Wrong With the World
  • Other Christian Resources

    • Blue Letter Bible
    • Chastity Resource for Men
    • Greek Bible
    • New Testament Gateway
  • Other Christian Websites

    • Consistent Life
    • NRCAT
    • Stand Firm
    • The Art of Manliness
  • Secular Websites

    • Almost Chosen People
    • American Cancer Society
    • American Conservative
    • American Conservative Union
    • American Education Reform
    • American Health Care Reform
    • American Life League
    • American Red Cross
    • Americans for Fair Tax
    • Americans United for Life
    • Asian Conservatives
    • Autism Society of America
    • Big Government
    • Big Hollywood
    • Black Genocide
    • Blue Dog Democrats
    • Breast Cancer Prevention Inst
    • Breitbart
    • C-SPAN
    • Care Net Pro Life Clinics
    • Choose Adoption
    • Citizens for Term Limits
    • Coalition on Abortn/Brst Cncr
    • Concerned Women For Amer…
    • Conservatives for Patients R…
    • Defend Marriage
    • Dem Congrsnl Campaign Cte
    • Dem Legisltv Campaign Cmte
    • Dem Senatrl Campaign Cmte
    • Democratic Gov Assoc
    • Democratic Ldrshp Council
    • Democratic Natl Convention
    • Democratic Party
    • Democrats for Life
    • Dems for Education Reform
    • Economic Policy Institute
    • Energy Independence Now
    • Face AIDS
    • Fair Economy
    • Faithful Democrats
    • Fathers for Life
    • Feminists for Life
    • First Things
    • Go Green Initiative
    • Health Care for the Homeless
    • House Democrats
    • Majella Society
    • Mediaite
    • Murder Victims Families for…
    • National Black Pro Life Union
    • National Right to Life
    • National Right to Work
    • Natl Cltn Abolish Death Pena…
    • Natl Rep Congressional Cmte
    • Natl Rep Senatorial Cmte
    • NewsBusters
    • Nurses for Life
    • PeaceCorps
    • Physicians for Life
    • Politico
    • Poverty.com
    • Pro Life OB|GYNS
    • Project 21
    • Raging Elephants
    • RealClearMarkets
    • RealClearPolitics
    • RealClearWorld
    • reason.tv
    • Redeem The Vote
    • Rep State Leadership Cmte
    • Repub for Envmntl Protec…
    • Republican Gov Assoc
    • Republican Jewish Coalition
    • Republican Ldshp Cncl
    • Republican Natl Convention
    • Republican Party
    • Repubs for Single Payer
    • Save Darfur
    • SBA List
    • Senate Democrats
    • Stop Human Trafficking
    • Suicide Prevention
    • The Daily Caller
    • The Other McCain
    • The Polycarp Research Inst.
    • The White House
    • US House of Representatives
    • US Senate
    • Women for Faith & Family
    • Women in Congress
  • Pages

    • Comments Policy
    • Contributors
    • What is The American Catholic?
  • Most Popular Tags

    Abortion Abraham Lincoln America American History Anti-Catholicism Barack Obama Bart Stupak Big Government Bigotry Catholic Chaplains Catholic Church Catholicism Catholic Social Teaching Christianity Civil War Conservatism Culture Culture of Death Culture of Life Democratic Party Democrats Dissident Catholics Distributism Economics Economy Election 2008 Election 2010 Fun Stuff God Government-Funded Abortion Government-Run Health Care Government Spending Health Care Reform History Holy Bible Homosexuality Humor Islam Jesuits Jesus Christ Joe Biden Liberalism Marriage Music Music Video Nancy Pelosi Obama Administration ObamaCare Planned Parenthood Political Philosophy Political Rhetoric Politics Pop Culture Pope Benedict XVI Pope John Paul II Pope Leo XIII Pro-Abortion Pro-Choice Pro-Life Pro-Life Movement Religion Republican Party Sacred Scripture Sarah Palin Scandal Socialism Ted Kennedy U.S. Congress U.S. Constitution U.S. Supreme Court University of Notre Dame USCCB Vatican Vatican II World War II
  • Authors

    • Blackadder
    • Ryan Harkins
    • Christopher Blosser
    • Zach
    • David Curp
    • DarwinCatholic
    • Dave Hartline
    • Donald R. McClarey
    • Chris Burgwald
    • Elaine Krewer
    • Joe of St. Thérèse
    • Justin Aquila
    • John Henry
    • David Jones
    • michaelrdenton
    • MJAndrew
    • Paul Zummo
    • Tim Shipe
    • The TAC Editors
    • Tito Edwards
    • Walter
  • Our Readers…

  • Meta

    • Register
    • Log in
    • Entries feed
    • Comments feed
    • WordPress.com


Blog at WordPress.com.

Privacy & Cookies: This site uses cookies. By continuing to use this website, you agree to their use.
To find out more, including how to control cookies, see here: Cookie Policy
  • Follow Following
    • The American Catholic
    • Join 141 other followers
    • Already have a WordPress.com account? Log in now.
    • The American Catholic
    • Customize
    • Follow Following
    • Sign up
    • Log in
    • Report this content
    • View site in Reader
    • Manage subscriptions
    • Collapse this bar
 

Loading Comments...