The American Catholic

Politics & Culture from a Catholic perspective
  • Home
  • Comments Policy
  • Contributors
  • What is The American Catholic?
 

Why Aren’t There More Worker Co-Ops?

Monday, May 10, 2010 \AM\.\Mon\.

Despite their obvious potential advantages, employee owned businesses tend to be rare. In 2004, there were an estimated 300 worker owned cooperatives in the United States. If that sounds impressive, consider that in 2001, there were over 18.3 million nonfarm proprietorships in the U.S. Nor is the situation much different overseas. The Mondragon Cooperative Corporation is typically cited as an example of a successful worker cooperative, and it is indeed quite successful . . . for a co-op. Compared to other types of businesses, however, Mondragon performs well, but not stellar. It is the seventh largest corporation in Spain, and despite being a conglomeration of more than a 100 different companies, it accounts for less than 4% of the GDP of the Basque region of Spain where it is located. When one considers that Mondragon is in all likelihood the most successful worker cooperative on the planet, the idea that the co-op’s success proves the viability of worker cooperatives generally begins to seem doubtful.

There’s nothing legally preventing people from choosing to start a workers-owned cooperative rather than some other form of business, and in fact cooperatives receive more favorable tax treatment than do standard business corporations. Why then, aren’t they more common? The question has actually inspired a fair amount of research, which has identified at least four obstacles to the success of worker owned businesses.

Read the rest of this entry »

7 Comments | Uncategorized | Tagged: Catholic Social Teaching, Cooperatives, Distributism, G.K. Chesterton, Hilaire Belloc, Mondragon Corporacion Cooperativa, Pope Leo XIII, Pope Pius XI, Principle of Subsidiarity, Quadragesimo Anno, Rerum Novarum, Social Solidarity | Permalink
Posted by Blackadder


  • Recent Posts

    • “A riot is the language of the unheard” – Understanding Martin Luther King in context
    • 10 Most Cited Arguments In Favor of the Mandate
    • The Battle of New Orleans The Hollywood Way
    • Andrew Jackson: Hero, Heel or Both?
    • “Feed your Flock” Superbowl Ad
    • Pope approves restricted use of condoms in battle against AIDS?
    • We Are At the-american-catholic.com
    • TAC Down Until Sunday Evening, November 14
    • Profiles in Fecklessness
    • Rocky Top
    • A Question for Our Readers
    • MacIntyre on Money
    • Jihadists, Truth and Father Raymond J. de Souza
    • The European Union: A Disaster for Equality, Etc.
    • CS Lewis Explains Why We Honor Veterans
  • Recent Comments

    Leo Holahan on 10 Most Cited Arguments In Fav…
    Rez Families on Sex, the Fall, and the Re…
    Kewaza on Atheist Praises Missionaries
    The Christian Vegan on Andrew Jackson: Hero, Heel or…
    Monica on Simply Outrageous
    Jacques from france on How Europe Sees America
    Tommy on An Example to Us All
    Mariana on Marriage Improvement
    redmetta on Clear Creek Monastery
    best carry holster on Should Catholics Own Guns…
    รายได้เสริมทางเน็ต on Pope Paul VI and The Smoke of…
    witnesstolife on Archbishop Niederauer Instruct…
    dota 2 beta start da… on Married Priests From the First…
    Lying Worthless Poli… on Pelosi, Saint Joseph and the C…
    truck guide on On Distributism and the Futili…
  • Top Posts – Last 24 Hours

    • The Omega Glory
    • Anne Rice's "Memnoch The Devil"
  • RealCatholicTV.com

  • Get Our Feed!

     Subscribe in a reader

    Subscribe in Bloglines

    Catholic Homepage

    Add to My AOL

    Add to Technorati Favorites

    Add to The Free Dictionary

    Add to Excite MIX

    Add to netvibes

    Subscribe to American Catholic

  • Enter your email address to subscribe to this blog and receive notifications of new posts by email.

    Join 142 other followers

  • December 2019
    M T W T F S S
    « Nov    
     1
    2345678
    9101112131415
    16171819202122
    23242526272829
    3031  
  • Archives

    • November 2014
    • March 2012
    • May 2011
    • December 2010
    • November 2010
    • October 2010
    • September 2010
    • August 2010
    • July 2010
    • June 2010
    • May 2010
    • April 2010
    • March 2010
    • February 2010
    • January 2010
    • December 2009
    • November 2009
    • October 2009
    • September 2009
    • August 2009
    • July 2009
    • June 2009
    • May 2009
    • April 2009
    • March 2009
    • February 2009
    • January 2009
    • December 2008
    • November 2008
    • October 2008
  • Catholic Bible Links

    • Biblia Clerus
    • Douay-Rheims
    • Latin Vulgate
    • New American Bible (USCCB)
    • Revised Std Version Cth Ed
    • Scripture Catholic
    • Septuagint/Vulgate/Douay
    • St Paul Ctr … Biblical Theology
    • Sunday Scripture Study
  • Catholic Blogroll

    • A Catholic Mom in Hawaii
    • Acts of the Apostasy
    • Against The Grain
    • An Examined Life
    • and sometimes tea
    • Biblical Evidence for Catholici…
    • Bonfire of the Vanities
    • Cahiers Péguy
    • Catholic Free Shipping Blog
    • Catholic Light
    • Catholic Phoenix
    • Conversion Diary
    • Cosmos-Liturgy-Sex
    • CVSTOS FIDEI
    • Disputations
    • Fidelity to the Word
    • Gulf Coast Catholic
    • la nouvelle théologie
    • Mary Meets Dolly
    • Per Christum
    • Riparians at the Gate
    • Sacramentum Vitae
    • SoCon or Bust
    • The Catholic Comedy
    • The Catholic Key Blog
    • The Curt Jester
    • The Divine Life
    • The Minor Premise
    • Video Meliora
    • Vivificat!
    • Whosoever Desires
  • Catholic Commentary

    • Catholic and Enjoying It!
    • Catholic Exchange
    • Catholic Fire
    • CVSTOS FIDEI
    • Damian Thompson
    • DarwinCatholic
    • Dyspeptic Mutterings
    • Evangelical Catholicism
    • George Weigel
    • Journeys in Alterity
    • Lair of the Catholic Cavemen
    • National Catholic Register
    • Non Nobis
    • Opinionated Catholic
    • Standing on My Head
    • Ten Reasons
    • The Catholic Thing
    • The Pertinacious Papist
    • What Does the Prayer Really…
  • Catholic New Media Links

    • Catholic Cartoon Blog
    • Catholic Media Review
    • Decent Films Guide
    • Eternal Word TV Network
    • Faith & Family
    • Gloria TV
    • Gulf Coast Catholic
    • RealCatholicTV.com
    • Rome Reports
    • Sonitus Sanctus
    • sqpn
    • The Catholicism Project
    • Vatican YouTube Channel
  • Catholic News Links

    • Catholic Culture
    • Catholic Online
    • Catholic Tide
    • Life Site News
    • National Catholic Register
    • New Advent – Catholic News
    • Notes on the Culture Wars
    • PewSitter.com
    • Real Clear Religion
    • Spirit Daily
    • Zenit
  • Catholic Orthodox Links

    • Canon Law by Dr. Ed Peters
    • CVSTOS FIDEI
    • FSSP
    • Gulf Coast Catholic
    • Legion of Mary
    • Musica Sacra
    • National Cthlc Bioethics Center
    • Natural Family Planning
    • Opus Dei
    • RORATE CÆLI
    • The Distributist Review
    • The New Liturgical Movement
  • Catholic Political Links

    • American Papist
    • Blackadders Lair
    • Catholic Advocate
    • CatholicVote.com
    • Civics Geeks
    • Creative Minority Report
    • CVSTOS FIDEI
    • For the Greater Glory
    • InsideCatholic.com
    • Matt Glassman
    • Mirror of Justice
    • Pro Ecclesia
    • Southern Appeal
    • The Anchoress
    • The Cranky Conservative
    • Thoughts of a Regular Guy
  • Catholic Radio Links

    • Ave Maria Radio
    • EWTN Radio
    • Relevant Radio
    • Vatican Radio
  • Catholic Resources

    • African-American Outreach
    • Black Catholic History
    • Byzantine Cthlc Church (US)
    • Catechism (CCC)
    • Catholic Dads Resources
    • Catholic Encyclopedia
    • Catholic Free Shipping
    • Catholic Liturgical Library
    • Catholic Search Engine
    • Catholic Social Doctrine
    • Catholic Social Teaching
    • Catholic Theology Resources
    • Catholics Come Home
    • Code of Canon Law
    • Compendium of the CCC
    • Cth Legal Immigration Net Inc
    • CVSTOS FIDEI
    • Decree on Ecumenism
    • Domestic Church
    • Early Christian Writings
    • Ecumenical Councils
    • Faithful Citizenship
    • Gulf Coast Catholic
    • Mass Times
    • National Cthlc AIDS Network
    • Natl Fellowship of Cthlc Men
    • Papal Encyclicals
    • Pope John Paul II Writings
    • Universalis
  • Catholic TV Links

    • CatholicTV
    • RealCatholicTV.com
  • Catholic Websites

    • Acton Institute
    • Against The Grain
    • Bellarmine Veritas Ministry
    • Black Catholics for Life
    • C-FAM
    • Cardinal Newman Society
    • Catholic Answers
    • Catholic Environmental Justice
    • Catholic Health Care USA
    • Catholic Hierarchy
    • Catholic Leadership Institute
    • Catholic League
    • Catholic Med Assoc
    • Catholic PeaceBuilding Net…
    • Catholic Relief Services
    • Clear Creek Monastery
    • Courage
    • Cth Resource For Porn Addicts
    • Cthlc Campaign for Hmn Dev…
    • Cthlc Education Resource Cntr
    • Cthlc Worker Movement
    • Cthlcs for the Common Good
    • Cths Against Capital Pnshmnt
    • Emmaus Ministries
    • Fathers for Good
    • FOCUS
    • Gulf Coast Catholic
    • Human Life International
    • Invisible Children
    • Knights of Columbus
    • Knights of Saint Peter Clav…
    • Make Poverty History
    • March for Life
    • Mercy Corps
    • Militia of the Immaculata
    • National Black Cthlc Congress
    • National Catholic Register
    • National Cthlc Youth Confere…
    • Pope Benedict XVI Fan Club
    • Priests for Life
    • Pro-Life America
    • Project Vote Smart
    • Pure Love Club
    • Rachels Vineyard
    • The Rosarium
    • USCCB
    • Vatican: English Site
    • Vatican: Latin Site
    • Word On Fire Cthlc Ministries
  • Jewish Websites

    • Pave the Way Foundation
  • Muslim Websites

    • Am Islamic Forum for Dmcrcy
    • Center for Islamic Pluralism
    • Muslim Canadian Congress
  • Orthodox Blogs

    • Notes on Arab Orthodoxy
    • The Burning Bush
  • Other Christian Blogs

    • Midwest Conservative Journal
    • The Anglo-Catholic
    • The Buck Stops Here
    • What's Wrong With the World
  • Other Christian Resources

    • Blue Letter Bible
    • Chastity Resource for Men
    • Greek Bible
    • New Testament Gateway
  • Other Christian Websites

    • Consistent Life
    • NRCAT
    • Stand Firm
    • The Art of Manliness
  • Secular Websites

    • Almost Chosen People
    • American Cancer Society
    • American Conservative
    • American Conservative Union
    • American Education Reform
    • American Health Care Reform
    • American Life League
    • American Red Cross
    • Americans for Fair Tax
    • Americans United for Life
    • Asian Conservatives
    • Autism Society of America
    • Big Government
    • Big Hollywood
    • Black Genocide
    • Blue Dog Democrats
    • Breast Cancer Prevention Inst
    • Breitbart
    • C-SPAN
    • Care Net Pro Life Clinics
    • Choose Adoption
    • Citizens for Term Limits
    • Coalition on Abortn/Brst Cncr
    • Concerned Women For Amer…
    • Conservatives for Patients R…
    • Defend Marriage
    • Dem Congrsnl Campaign Cte
    • Dem Legisltv Campaign Cmte
    • Dem Senatrl Campaign Cmte
    • Democratic Gov Assoc
    • Democratic Ldrshp Council
    • Democratic Natl Convention
    • Democratic Party
    • Democrats for Life
    • Dems for Education Reform
    • Economic Policy Institute
    • Energy Independence Now
    • Face AIDS
    • Fair Economy
    • Faithful Democrats
    • Fathers for Life
    • Feminists for Life
    • First Things
    • Go Green Initiative
    • Health Care for the Homeless
    • House Democrats
    • Majella Society
    • Mediaite
    • Murder Victims Families for…
    • National Black Pro Life Union
    • National Right to Life
    • National Right to Work
    • Natl Cltn Abolish Death Pena…
    • Natl Rep Congressional Cmte
    • Natl Rep Senatorial Cmte
    • NewsBusters
    • Nurses for Life
    • PeaceCorps
    • Physicians for Life
    • Politico
    • Poverty.com
    • Pro Life OB|GYNS
    • Project 21
    • Raging Elephants
    • RealClearMarkets
    • RealClearPolitics
    • RealClearWorld
    • reason.tv
    • Redeem The Vote
    • Rep State Leadership Cmte
    • Repub for Envmntl Protec…
    • Republican Gov Assoc
    • Republican Jewish Coalition
    • Republican Ldshp Cncl
    • Republican Natl Convention
    • Republican Party
    • Repubs for Single Payer
    • Save Darfur
    • SBA List
    • Senate Democrats
    • Stop Human Trafficking
    • Suicide Prevention
    • The Daily Caller
    • The Other McCain
    • The Polycarp Research Inst.
    • The White House
    • US House of Representatives
    • US Senate
    • Women for Faith & Family
    • Women in Congress
  • Pages

    • Comments Policy
    • Contributors
    • What is The American Catholic?
  • Most Popular Tags

    Abortion Abraham Lincoln America American History Anti-Catholicism Barack Obama Bart Stupak Big Government Bigotry Catholic Chaplains Catholic Church Catholicism Catholic Social Teaching Christianity Civil War Conservatism Culture Culture of Death Culture of Life Democratic Party Democrats Dissident Catholics Distributism Economics Economy Election 2008 Election 2010 Fun Stuff God Government-Funded Abortion Government-Run Health Care Government Spending Health Care Reform History Holy Bible Homosexuality Humor Islam Jesuits Jesus Christ Joe Biden Liberalism Marriage Music Music Video Nancy Pelosi Obama Administration ObamaCare Planned Parenthood Political Philosophy Political Rhetoric Politics Pop Culture Pope Benedict XVI Pope John Paul II Pope Leo XIII Pro-Abortion Pro-Choice Pro-Life Pro-Life Movement Religion Republican Party Sacred Scripture Sarah Palin Scandal Socialism Ted Kennedy U.S. Congress U.S. Constitution U.S. Supreme Court University of Notre Dame USCCB Vatican Vatican II World War II
  • Authors

    • Blackadder
    • Ryan Harkins
    • Christopher Blosser
    • Zach
    • David Curp
    • DarwinCatholic
    • Dave Hartline
    • Donald R. McClarey
    • Chris Burgwald
    • Elaine Krewer
    • Joe of St. Thérèse
    • Justin Aquila
    • John Henry
    • David Jones
    • michaelrdenton
    • MJAndrew
    • Paul Zummo
    • Tim Shipe
    • The TAC Editors
    • Tito Edwards
    • Walter
  • Our Readers…

  • Meta

    • Register
    • Log in
    • Entries feed
    • Comments feed
    • WordPress.com


Create a free website or blog at WordPress.com.

Privacy & Cookies: This site uses cookies. By continuing to use this website, you agree to their use.
To find out more, including how to control cookies, see here: Cookie Policy